Tuesday, 4 September 2012

Heroic Fantasy Roleplaying, Part 1

Thoughts on using Marvel Heroic Roleplaying for games in the traditional Fantasy Gaming style.

Part 1: Powers and Names

Marvel Heroic Roleplaying (MHR) (generally) uses a simple scale of three broad categories for powers: Enhanced, Superhuman and Godlike. A few powers have different labels, such as the movement powers, but those use tiers analogous to the E/S/G levels.

But Godlike is probably a bit much for most fantasy settings (unless you're playing Exalted or Scion, perhaps), so we're going to need to redefine the power levels here for something that fits the less city-breaking scale of most fantasy games.

So, firstly, an assumption: The characters in this game are not going to be “average Joe/Jane who picked up a sword”. Our baseline for anything worthy of having a rating will therefore be above average, and have to go up to covering most monsters.

In MHR, Enhanced also covers 'peak' human characters like Daredevil and Captain America. This is as low as our ratings go. Any character with at least a d8 rating can be called a Heroic Character, which means that the d8 is the lowest Heroic stat.

Enhanced therefore becomes Heroic. This marks the character out as being above-and-beyond the average citizen but not beyond the realms of possibility.

At the other end, we have a category that needs to cover things up to the strength of a giant or the resilience of a dragon. Though some Heroic Characters may reach these giddy heights this is largely the purview of monsters.

Godlike therefore becomes Monstrous. This is the top end of our scale.

Which leaves us needing a middle ground rating to cover d10s. My basic inclination is to rate d10s as Paragon, well beyond the abilities of most people.

Superhuman therefore becomes Paragon.

All of this gives us the power tiers of

Heroic (d8)
Paragon (d10)
Monstrous (d12)

Although, all this talk of tiers suggests another approach to the labelling of powers inspired by Dungeons & Dragons 4th Edition:

Heroic (d8)
Paragon (d10)
Epic (d12)

And I feel stupid for not thinking of that earlier.

I'd actually be tempted to use the latter set for Heroic Characters (ie. PCs and major NPCs) and the former set for adversarial characters.

No comments:

Post a Comment